Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Fake diplomas of Singapore private schools and foreign universities on sale

The New Paper, Mar 3, 2012 (source)


Failed to make the cut at a private school here? You can still get a certificate - a fake one. This is what advertisements on local online Chinese language forums are offering..

The certificates are counterfeits of those issued by private education institutions (PEI) in Singapore.

When contacted, the PEIs named in these ads said they condemned the actions of the sellers.

Two PEI have filed police reports.

The online advertisements offering fake certificates from private education institutions (PEIs) in Singapore scream with promises.

Promises such as the quality of the fake certs and how they can help buyers secure jobs here and abroad.

Touting their services as "reliable", "fast" and "safe", the sellers claimed to offer counterfeit certificates from up to 10 PEIs here.

The institutions included the Management Development Institute of Singapore (MDIS), Curtin Singapore, Kaplan Singapore, Informatics and the Singapore Institute of Management (SIM).

The advertisements are aimed at Chinese nationals who failed to get their desired grades here and fear being unable to apply for jobs when they return to China.

Some of the advertisements said in Chinese: "Believe in us, believe in yourself! We can help you solve your problems."

When The New Paper contacted eight of the PEIs, five said it was the first time they had heard of online counterfeiters targeting their institutions.

Two of them have since filed police reports on this matter, with MDIS confirming it was one of the two.

Its spokesman told TNP that the school's management takes "a serious view" of the matter.

"We will not hesitate to institute legal action against the person(s) involved," he said.

A police spokesman confirmed the report and that investigations are ongoing.

TNP was alerted to the advertisements that have been circulating since last November on at least four local Chinese forums here by a concerned member of the public.

Recruiting agents

Some of the advertisements even promised the ability to create not only certificates but also postgraduate degrees from universities in the UK, Canada and other countries.

Other advertisements said the sellers are recruiting agents and urged people to contact them via QQ, an instant messaging software popular in China.

It is not known who the sellers are. But based on three of the profiles TNP found on QQ, they include men and women who claim to be based in Singapore.

One male seller, who lists his age as 37 on his QQ profile, claims to have graduated from Nanyang Technological University (NTU).

The most updated post by a seller was last Saturday. In it, he said he had a 24-hour hotline and was "professional".

TNP tried to contact the sellers, but our calls and messages went unanswered.

Channel NewsAsia's report last Friday said some of the certificates were going for as much as $10,000.

That report also said that while the sellers were able to produce certificates for any course, the most popular courses were business management and tourism.

This is not the first time fake education certificates have surfaced in Singapore.

Two years ago, TNP broke the story of fake degrees from National University of Singapore (NUS), Singapore Management University (SMU) and NTU being sold here.

At that time, the counterfeiters were found to be based in Singapore and China, and the fake degrees were available for from a few hundred dollars to $4,000.

Several of the PEIs contacted over the last two days were surprised by the sellers' audacity and said they had been unaware until TNP informed them.

The spokesman for Informatics said the sellers were "unethical".

A spokesman for Kaplan Singapore said: "We are surprised by the boldness of these illegal sales tactics.

"(Despite the) strict regulations in Singapore, there are still people willing to take the risk of such illegal dealings."

Many of the PEIs contacted by TNP said there are ways to tell an authentic certificate from their institutions from a fake one.

But some were nevertheless concerned about the impact of bogus certs on the private education industry here as well as Singapore's reputation as a provider of quality education.


Mr Er Kwong Wah, executive director of the East Asia Institute of Management (EASB), said: "We do not relish such activities, as fake certificates using any PEI's name will be detrimental to the good standing of the private education industry."

Many of the PEIs whose certificates were advertised on the online forums said they have reported this matter to the Council for Private Education (CPE), a statutory board which regulates the private education sector.

CPE's spokesman said it viewed the matter "seriously".

"The selling of fake degrees is a matter of cheating and forgery and a crime under the Penal Code," the spokesman added.

"The CPE has advised the PEIs affected to make police reports. The CPE will also extend its assistance to the police in their investigations."

Some PEIs have either started or completed their own internal investigations.

Mr Er said EASB's internal inquiry concluded that "none of our staff was involved in providing such certificates, and that our internal processes in the preparation and production of certificates were not compromised".

He added that EASB's principal has also spoken to all the students to impress upon them that the use of fake certificates is criminal for both buyers and sellers.

Kaplan Singapore's spokesman agreed, adding: "We are concerned for students, especially those who fall for such traps as an easy way out, which ultimately may hurt their career and future."

Real certs have security features

The Chinese embassy faxed to the East Asia Institute of Management (EASB) three certificates for its authentication last year.

EASB's executive director, Mr Er Kwong Wah, said the school checked the names of the students against its records and confirmed that no such certificates were issued.

"We accordingly informed the Chinese embassy that we had not issued these three certificates and we could not authenticate the documents," he said.

He explained that each EASB certificate has a security number and only the school can verify the authenticity of the documents.

"Our certificate is of non-standard size and carries a special watermark that is difficult to copy."

Other PEIs here that The New Paper spoke to said their certificates also have distinct characteristics.

Kaplan Singapore certificates come sealed with a hologram, which marks the authenticity of its certificates.

Kaplan's university partners also have in place their own measures which authenticate their certificates in the form of watermarks and other markings.

Kaplan also keeps records of its students, together with their programme details and codes.

This is also done by PSB Academy, whose spokesman said: "Our certificates are issued with serial numbers tagged to each graduand's name and the programme which they had graduated from.

"The list of graduands are reviewed and approved by the examination board before the certificates are issued."

The spokesman added that PSB's certificates in partnership with the Cambridge International Examinations (CIE) come with the CIE strip that is "authentic and not easily duplicated".

Check it

In any case, employers can always check on the validity of a PSB certificate with the school, he said.

The same goes with Curtin Singapore.

Said its pro vice-chancellor, Professor John Neilson: "The authenticity of a Curtin award certificate can be confirmed by contacting the Curtin University Graduations Office or by checking against the school's Online Award Verification Service."

In light of the latest incidents of fake certificates being peddled online, MDIS' spokesman said: "We want to assure all MDIS students that all certificates issued from MDIS are genuine."


Scammers peddling fake Singapore diplomas and certificates

SG.CHINESE.NET moderator sticky thread on fake degree



Stolen fees and fake certificates: Lily Kong of Singapore and Dicky Wong of Hong Kong sue each other

Straits Times, May 16, 2009 (source)

TWO private schools in Singapore are suing their Hong Kong-based marketing agent for holding on to money collected from students and schools in China.

Yesterday, Madam Lily Kong (江莉莉), the schools' principal and owner, told the High Court that she wanted the agent to stop issuing fake certificates and receipts in the name of her schools.

She claimed that he had stolen the identity of her institutions and spoilt their good name.

The two schools are Orchard School of Arts and Commerce and Singapore Commercial School, both of which also run hostels.

They are suing Mr Dicky Wong (黄世仰)and his two companies. One of them is International Education Advisory Centre (IEAC) in Hong Kong, which recruits students for schools worldwide; the other is Singkong Group, a local company that operates a hostel in Martaban Road.

The plaintiffs, which are unrepresented by lawyers, are seeking some $7 million and various restraining orders. The defendants, represented by Mr Andrew Yeo, have counter-sued for $5 million for lost and potentially lost commission and fees.

In 2002, the two Singapore schools appointed IEAC to recruit students from Hong Kong and China. They also had agreements with schools in China to run collaborative courses that gave students the chance to spend a year in Singapore.

The two schools are now claiming that the agent secretly kept student fees from 2004 to 2007. They also claim that he started his own agreements with the Chinese schools and that he diverted their students to other schools and to his own hostel.

The schools allege that even after they ended their agreement, Mr Wong and his firm continued to recruit students using their material.

Both parties do not agree about their contracts.

The plaintiffs said they had an agreement, made in 2003, in which the agent was to arrange for students to pay their fees directly to the schools.

But the defendants said there was an October 2004 agreement stating that the schools in China would deposit fees with IEAC, which would wire the money to Singapore. That agreement also gives IEAC the right to sign cooperation agreements with the China schools.

Madam Kong denied having signed this deal and told the court Mr Wong had forged the document.

The defendants also said it was the Chinese schools that had decided against the two Singapore schools after students had problems in 2006.


Nov 2007 (source)

$200,000 fee discrepancy may cost school dearly
Orchard School cannot take in more foreign students until accounts are fixed

A PRIVATE school in Telok Kurau has had its CaseTrust status suspended after discrepancies were discovered in its student tuition fees account.

The Consumers Association of Singapore (Case) states on its website that the school's status was suspended about three weeks ago.

The suspension is a problem because the school relies heavily on foreign students and without CaseTrust accreditation, it cannot do so.

Case executive director Seah Seng Choon said yesterday: 'We are able to reveal only that Orchard School of Arts and Commerce has been suspended as it was in breach of CaseTrust criteria.'

However, The New Paper understands that the suspension was mainly due to a discrepancy in the school's accounts.

It is understood that the school had also failed to inform Case that it could no longer conduct one of its courses.

However, the Orchard School of Arts and Commerce has pinned the blame of the discrepancies on three of its agents.

The school's principal, Madam Lily Kong, is optimistic that the suspension will be 'lifted soon'.


She explained that the discrepancies came about because their agents for overseas students did not pay the school fees owed to it.

When asked how much they owed altogether, she said: 'Close to $200,000.'

Of the three agents, one is giving the school a lot of problems, Madam Kong said, adding that that the school has engaged a lawyer to pursue legal action against the agent.

The school filed its lawsuit against the agent and some others about a month ago.

Meanwhile, she said, the school has been 'chasing after' the other two agents for payments, and there is less of a discrepancy now.

The school, which runs English courses, a diploma course in accommodation operations and a postgraduate diploma course in strategic business IT, said it has about 200 foreign students.

It does not have any local students at the moment, the principal said, as the last batch has finished their courses for this year. The school's next intake of local students will be in January.

Meanwhile, as long as its CaseTrust status remains suspended, the school cannot enrol new foreign students.

Madam Kong, who set up the Orchard school in 1987, said: 'Case knows that we are resolving the problems. We are trying to sort it out.'

Mr Seah said that since 2005, Case has handled 32 cases concerning the school. Most of them concerned feedback about the school.

In at least eight of the cases, Case had to intervene to help settle the dispute.

Madam Kong said many of the complaints about the unsatisfactory services provided were not genuine.

She claimed that students who were absent from class complained when the school refused to mark their attendance.

Since 1 Sep 2005, private schools have not been allowed to take in foreign students without CaseTrust status.

CaseTrust recognises private schools with good student welfare practices and high quality standards along with clear fee policies and well-defined student redress practices and systems.


Who is the scammer: Lily Kong or Dicky Wong or both? 

Shenzhen vocational school sues Lily Kong and Singapore Commercial School
Tangled tale of Singapore Commercial School and a vocational school in Shenzhen, China


2009-12-03 15:15:00 来源: 深圳新闻网(深圳) 

深圳市华强职业技术学校和新加坡商业学院(Singapore Commercial School)合作开办酒店管理课程,21名学生学习后,有学生及家长投诉“拿到的是假文凭”。而新加坡商业学院校长江莉莉Lily Kong也声称他们没有介入到实际的联合办学中,且没有收到任何联合办学的费用……这是近日几家媒体报道的华强职校合作办学“发假文凭”事件,引起市民广泛关注。
昨日,华强职校张健校长接受了记者采访。 华强职校与新加坡商业学院的协议书,双方校长张健与江莉莉签字。






2009年07月01日 (来源)






2009年07月22日 10:34 來源:中國青年報




No comments: